Communities and energy projects: Trust is everything, says study

Think local opposition is based on climate change? Think again

What’s the secret sauce for energy project approval in Canada?

According to the Canada West Foundation, it boils down to trust—not climate change.

A non-partisan think tank, the Canada West Foundation recently announced the results of a study seeking to understand what drives community confidence in the energy project decision-making process.

Local opposition to energy infrastructure, and the concerns that create that opposition, “are often not what opinion leaders and political decision-makers have assumed,” reads the study, which was produced by the CWF and the University of Ottawa. “Importantly, local opposition is not restricted to pipelines and oil sands, and it is often not about climate change.”

The CWF study examined six recently proposed Canadian energy projects, including gas-fired power plants, a hydroelectric dam, a wind farm and a power transmission line. Its research showed various factors to be “far more important” to local communities than climate change, including:

  • Safety;
  • Need;
  • Distribution of benefits;
  • Local environmental impacts;
  • Restrictive consultation or communication practices; and
  • Local involvement in decision making.

Context is everything, and the simple promise of economic benefits is no longer enough to sway local communities, according to the report—which calls for a total “rethink” of the way energy infrastructure projects are proposed, communicated and regulated.

“Local authorities and communities are demanding an increasing role in how economic and environmental decisions by third parties affect their future,” says the CWF report. “One thing seems very clear—the world of elite, centralized decision-making without local engagement is fast becoming a thing of the past.”

Canadians agreeable to an all-of-the-above energy strategy, new poll suggests

Approving a pipeline, while encouraging a shift toward renewables, would create ‘a path to consensus’: Abacus Data.

In the news: Is Canada being left behind?

Two interesting stories in the media this week you may be interested in.

Energy Matters

In the world's conversation about energy, one point is beyond debate: Energy makes a vital contribution to people's quality of life, to society and to human progress. This is true today, and it will remain true in the future. That's why Energy Matters was created. We believe it's important to equip people with unbiased information so they may form opinions, join the conversation and feel confidence in the work and accomplishments of the energy sector. Energy Matters is an initiative that provides transparent information and perspective on energy. Here, we'll cover a range of topics: the scale of global energy; the ways energy is sourced and produced; current energy technology; forthcoming innovations; the world's future energy needs; and the sustainable sources of energy that will fill them. Because energy matters to everyone, we hope you'll rely on Energy Matters as an ongoing source of balanced information.